|
Image courtesy of Wikipedia. |
A few years after the Spice Girls spiced up my life, TLC came along to continue my feminist education. Since "No Scrubs" was
everywhere, the TLC album I selected in the record store was
FanMail. In retrospect,
FanMail was vastly inappropriate for a middle schooler, but as I've found is usually the case, I ignored the songs that I was too young for and passionately loved the songs I understood. I also knew better than to listen to the CD without headphones.
Listening to the album was like eavesdropping on an older sister and her best friends, women who were loyal and funny and sexy and
took no shit. Middle school me could only dream of being that confident. When I listen to the album now, I hear pieces of high school, of college, of my young adult life. "No Scrubs" happened to come up last week at work. Every teacher in my generation started singing the chorus from memory. TLC was
that kind of talent.
FanMail isn't even their best album, but TLC's personality sparkles from (almost) every track.
Now, because this is a nostalgic album review, I have to talk about the song that was most important to me in middle school:
Go ahead, find me a middle school girl who thinks she's pretty. I'd promise to wait, but I'd wait for an awfully long time. I was not an attractive middle schooler. I had a round face, deeply unfortunate bangs, and enormous bifocals. I developed early, so people accused me of stuffing my bra and made fun of me for sitting with correct posture, even though my back hurt if I didn't. There are only a handful of pictures of me where I'm smiling. "Unpretty" was an older sister telling me that everyone felt unpretty sometimes. I didn't believe moralistic television episodes telling me
everybody is pretty in her own way! but I believed it when TLC sang,
But if you can't look inside you, find out who am I too, be in the position to make me feel so damn unpretty. It's the difference between being told what to think and being offered a slice of advice based on shared experience.
(Side note #1: The original music video is no longer available on YouTube, or at least not on TLC's official account. What's uploaded is a version that cuts the racist attack on T-Boz and the gang violence Left-Eye witnesses. But bulimia and breast implants are kid-friendly! I guess it's okay to feel bad about being a girl, as long as race and class never enter the equation. Way to be completely out of touch, YouTube.)
When I wasn't listening to "Unpretty" over and over, I promise I listened to the rest of the album, too. I can't hear the phrase "fan mail" without getting the titular song stuck in my head.
Just like you, I get lonely, too. TLC could create a hell of a hook, which we also got to hear in later tracks like "Silly Ho" and "I'm Good at Being Bad." Talk about two songs I could never play in front of my parents! I love that "I'm Good at Being Bad" works in a rap about using condoms or else:
If it's naked, I'll take it with the batteries and bake it! You know, in between the swaggering chorus and jokes about how
a hard man is so good to find. This is what I mean about TLC being the older sisters I never had.
(Side note #2: I heard the censored version of "I'm Good at Being Bad" for the first time while writing this album review. When you have to mute every third word, you have to question the point of a censored version.)
Aside from the amusing interludes scattered throughout the album, there are four remaining types of tracks: pretty-sounding if mostly sad ballads ("I Miss You So Much," "Come On Down," "Dear Lie," "Don't Pull Out On Me Yet"), R&B tracks that don't particularly stand out but still get stuck in your head ("If They Knew," "My Life," "Shout,") the boring ("Lovesick," "Automatic"), and "No Scrubs." Because as much as I love many of the tracks on
FanMail, I know that "No Scrubs" is in a class of its own, particularly the remix with Left-Eye's rap.
See, if you can't spatially expand my horizon, that leaves you in a class with scrubs, never risin'. I was one indignant middle schooler when I realized that the album version was different than the music video version. But the album version of "No Scrubs" was hardly settling. TLC taught me how to demand the love and respect I deserved.
Left-Eye, rest in peace and play us out.